Hicks Thomas LLP Obtains Defense Verdict For R.R. Street In California Water Contamination Case

From: Hicks Thomas LLP
Published: Sat May 23 2009


Attorneys from Houston-based Hicks Thomas LLP are announcing a take-nothing defense verdict handed down late yesterday in favor of Naperville, Ill.-based R.R. Street & Co. Inc. in a water contamination lawsuit filed by the City of Modesto, Calif.

The City of Modesto sued Street, Midland, Michigan-based Dow Chemical Company, Pittsburgh-based PPG Industries and others in 1998 based on claims that the companies failed to warn local dry cleaning businesses about the potential risks of a solvent that allegedly contaminated underground water. The chemical, perchloroethylene (PERC), is widely used in the U.S. dry cleaning industry.

Attorneys for the city claimed that city water wells at multiple sites were contaminated by PERC, and sought a verdict that would require the defendants to help pay for cleanup. However, San Francisco Superior Court Judge Ernest H. Goldsmith dismissed the majority of the sites from the case, finding that there was no evidence of damage to the city that was caused by the companies’ products.

The May 18, 2009 verdict found with respect to Street that the benefits of PERC outweighed any potential risks and that there was no failure to warn on the part of Street. Jurors assessed $18 million in damages against Dow Chemical and PPG for contamination at one of the well sites; however settlement credits from other defendants are expected to offset that award.

“R.R. Street has always worked with the highest standards for safety,” says John Thomas, a partner in Hicks Thomas and lead counsel for the company. “We are pleased that the jury carefully reviewed the facts in this case and found no wrongdoing by our client.”

In 2006, the city won a $3 million verdict in an earlier phase of the trial involving four additional well sites. That award was offset by recoveries the city made in settlements with other parties.

“As a company, the quality and safe use of our products is of utmost importance,” says L. Ross Beard, CEO of R.R. Street & Co. Inc. “We are gratified that the jury agreed that Street acted properly, and we would like to thank John and the rest of the Hicks Thomas team for their hard work.”

Founded in 1997, Hicks Thomas LLP is a premier litigation firm representing plaintiffs and defendants in Texas, California and across the nation. The firm's in-depth experience includes oil and gas, environmental, toxic tort, products liability, corporate governance, securities, banking, insurance coverage, transportation, and trade secrets litigation.

For more information, contact Alan Bentrup at 800-559-4534 (office), 713-553-3358 (cell) or alan@androvett.com.
Company: Hicks Thomas LLP
Contact Name: Alan Bentrup
Contact Email: alan@androvett.com
Contact Phone: 800-559-4534

Visit website »